The Life Of A LittlBUGer

Man, has it seriously been nearly 3 weeks since I posted here?  Damn me… damn me to hell!

Anyway, I have a couple of things to share today.  First off, one of my new projects at home was to setup a system where I could backup all of my music, photos, and DVDs/movies to a home server or some external HD even and then be able to play those directly on my TV.  I mainly wanted this because of my DVDs.  When you have kids, you end either losing DVDs, getting them ruined or broken, etc.  So by backing them up electronically and then playing them directly to the TV, nothing is lost and it’s easier and faster to actually get the movie started.

The first thing that happened that allowed this ‘dream’ to come to reality was when the company I work for was going to throw out some ‘old’ computers.  I said, hell, I’ll take one home.  So I did.  It is very basic, Celeron 2.4 Ghz CPU with 256 MB RAM, 80 GB HD, etc. but still, probably powerful enough to eventually stream some media to my TV.

So I began research a month or so ago into media players that would be some sort of set top box that I’d put under my TV along with my DVD player and whatnot.   I searched left and right to try and find the best deal and best band for the buck.  Everything kept pointing to the Apple TV, but since I loath Apple and it really wasn’t quite what I wanted anyway (as it required iTunes and whatnot other crap) I had to find the next best thing.  It seemed that next best thing was the DLink DSM-520.  So I ordered it, it came, I installed it relatively easy enough.  Then I read up on it some more.

It seems the best way for me to go about things was to use their media software on my ‘new’ home server to share the folders I wanted to share which had my movies and such and to also first re-encode all of my movies to mp4 format.  I figured this would be OK as I could still get the main movie at good quality with OK file size.  So I did this so several test movies, installed the software, poked holes in my firewall and such and then did some tests.  Took me a while to realize that the DSM-520, though it had built in wireless capability, just wasn’t going to cut it wirelessly.  not because of any slow downs in movie playing or anything, but just because I couldn’t really ever get anything to work.

So I decided, since my TV is upstairs in the living room and my home server is downstairs in my office, I should try the powerline ethernet adapters to allow an ethernet connection through my power lines in the house.  I bought a pair of 200 Mbps Adaptec ones and after a very easy setup, I could see the wired connectivity was there and working fine.  So I wired it to my router and then to the DSM-520 and hoped for the best.  Though things were slightly better, it was still a 50/50 chance that any movie would even start playing and the DSM-520 was still just generally slow and sluggish on the menu.  When it did actually play, it may skip every now and then during the movie and I found out the remote was absolutely horrible at doing any chapter skipping or fast forwarding and rewinding.

So I thought about upgrading the home server a bit (such as adding more RAM, adding in a dedicated sound and video card, new power supply, etc.) to see if that was the issue.  I ordered the parts, got them installed, tried everything again, and absolutely no change.  So I began posting on the DLink forums and whatnot and no one was of any help as I’ve already tried all of their suggestions software-wise and hardware-wise.  So now I’m fed up.

Being pissed off and frustrated at the same time, I decide to think things over a bit.  My setup was maybe a bit unique.  Though I had the home server, the actual media I was sharing was on a 500 GB external drive connected via USB to the home server.  It was stored, actually, on a Klegg 500 GB NetDisk.  So I thought… hmm… maybe it’s the Klegg drive, or maybe I need something from Klegg to make it work?  So I began looking at Klegg…

Soon I found what seemed to be quite a little and amazing device, the Klegg MediaShare.  It could do everything the DSM-520 could and then some.  It could even act as an enclosure, meaning I could put a HD directly into the device so I wouldn’t even need a server to stream media from.  So after more research, though I found the main website to contain barely any information and it was supposively sold at only one location, reviews were fairly good and I noticed it could potentially play .iso files directly!  This means that I could do a full backup (menus, extras, and all) of a DVD to a .iso file and it would play directly through that.  The other bonus was that it didn’t require any software, it just looked for any open shares or shared folders on the network.

So again, I put my faith in this new unit, purchased it, set it up replacing the DSM-520 and low and behold, though it could see my server, it didn’t see any shared folders though I explicitly shared them for this purpose.  I was instantly frustrated until I actually looked at the manual and noticed something.  When talking about sharing folders, it didn’t say anything about using Windows XP Pro and having Simple Sharing disabled, it went through instructions with Simple File Sharing ENABLED.  So I did just that, re-shared my folders, and voila, it can see them!  So I navigated through it’s menu and clicked on one of my .iso movies and viola, it starts playing immediately!

I was so overjoyed at this moment, I didn’t know what to do.  So I just watched the movie for a while to make sure all was OK, even tried the remote out which actually works as it should and was impressed.   So this basically helped conclude my overall project as I knew I had a working solution for what I wanted.  Sure, I would have to have larger files for the DVD backups and such, but hell, space is cheap these days.  I just wish I would have bought the Klegg MediaShare right off the bat!

So in conclusion, I’m going to give a nice big THUMBS UP to Klegg and a nice big THUMBS DOWN to DLink for comparable media sharing capabilities (who knew this post would turn into a review!).  I’ll also state some pros and cons for you that were the main points I looked into:

 DLink DSM-520

Pros:

• Lots of information and active updates and support from main website
• Comes from a huge and widely known company
• Somewhat large userbase
• Has a large menu and the ability to view YouTube and other videos from online
• Wireless and wired capabilities
• Basically silent operation

Cons:

• Can’t play directly from .iso files or other DVD file formats (such as .vob, etc.)
• Remote is just plain horrible
• Menus and loading times are quite slow
• The device itself is overly large
• Can’t act like an enclosure
• USB interface can’t handle larger external hard drives

Klegg MediaShare

Pros:

• Menus looks great and easy to navigate
• No slowness or sluggishness in menus
• Remote works as it should
• Can play directly from .iso or .vob files
• The device itself is quite small
• Is an enclosure so a HD can be added directly to the device thus bypassing the need for a server at all
• USB interface can handle larger external drives
• Wireless and wired capabilities

Cons:

• Comes with a fan to help cool internal HD (if you put one in) and thus is a bit nosier than I’d like
• Relatively no information or updates from main website
• Small userbase
• Pretty much unknown company (other than the fact they bought Ximeta I think)
• Can’t play YouTube or other videos directly from the internet

And of course, links to both products:

DLink DSM-520: http://www.dlink.com/products/?pid=438

Klegg MedisShare: http://www.kleggusa.com/product_mediashare.html